BAYOMOTO

Team Puerto Rico

Is Puerto Rico a country? Technically speaking, no. Does it have its own unique culture, traditions, and economy? Yes. Were some of the US territory’s riders at the 2008 Motocross of Nations originally from there? Sure. Did all of those riders have at least a miniscule connection to Puerto Rico despite not currently residing there, claiming it as their birth place, or having some family blood related to the small island? Nope, not at all.

Team Puerto Rico’s involvement in this year's Motocross of Nations was historical. Not because it was their first time competing: they attended the 2007 event. This year, though, the team qualified, and in doing so, had the first woman to ever compete in a men’s professional motocross race.

Tarah Geiger was born in Puerto Rico and lived there for most of her childhood, and is currently one of the fastest female racers in the world. She was not quite at the same speed as the rest of the field in her motos, but she held her own and represented her birthplace well. However, one of Puerto Rico’s riders did not represent his birthplace well at all, despite having one fantastic moto. Zach Osborne placed fifth in his first moto, but he is not from Puerto Rico, he has ever been to the island, nor does he having any heritage there.

Zach Osborne hails from Virginia, and as an amateur standout, was a shoe-in for a factory ride upon acquiring his professional license. With stints spent at both KTM and Yamaha of Troy here in the US, Osborne suffered through a few injury plagued
seasons before finding a spot on the British based U-Tag Yamaha team about halfway through the 2008 season. Contesting both the British National series and the World GP series, Zach had some outstanding rides, including one moto win in the latter series. Since the U-Tag team chose to help out Team Puerto Rico, why not bring on their star rider to help with the effort? I bring up this topic not out of an inquiry into national loyalty or patriotism, but more so in terms of the definition of the FIM Motocross of Nations rules.

The rules clearly state that a rider participating in the MXoN must hold a passport from the nation they are representing. Therein lies the problem. Puerto Rico, as stated earlier is not technically a country, but instead a United States Territory. The race is called the Motocross of Nations, not the Motocross of Places That May or May Not Be Nations But For the Sake of This Race We Will Call Them Nations Anyway. Not only does the MXoPTMoMNBNBFtSoTRWWCTNA sound ridiculous, it also deflates the prestige of the race.

The other issue is the rule about passports. Since Puerto Rico is a US Territory, its residents hold US passports. Zach Osborne holds a US passport, thus he was allowed to represent the small island of four million people. Using this logic, the US could essentially send a few teams of its best riders, one from the US, one from Puerto, one from Guam, and how about a few from the Virgin Islands just for kicks. Or, following that same line of thinking, each American state should be able to send a three-person team to the MXoN.

The Solution

The problem with Puerto Rico’s presence at the most important and longest running motocross race in the world has nothing to do with the island or its riders, the problem is the way in which the team was allowed to compete and the rules that were bent to get them there. In order to maintain prestige at a prestigious event, rules must be adhered to otherwise some legitimacy is lost.

1) The FIM could change the regulations to be more lenient so riders could represent the country of their choosing. Perhaps at least two of the team members would have to claim residence or hold a passport for the place they are representing, allowing one of the three team members to hold a passport from outside of the represented flag.

*This would fit with the situation Osborne found himself in, but again detracts from the prestige of the race.

2) Rules could be made more stringent, not only requiring a passport, but a rider must also currently claim residence in or have lived in the place the are representing for a minimum of, say, three years.

3) Expand the rules of what defines a nation for this particular event. Again, Puerto Rico is not a nation unto itself, and should technically not be allowed to compete, which would seem unfair by most standards. However, if the definition of a nation were simply expanded to include island territories and the like, with their own cultures, economies, and in some cases languages, they would be allowed to compete as long as they followed rule #2. This would allow places such as Puerto Rico, Scotland, and even Guadalupe to legitimately compete as a nation at this classic event with out any doubters.

I introduced this topic not as a naysayer, but as an absolute die-hard fan of motocross racing and the Motocross of Nations and what it stands for. The race is our sports World Cup, when the best three riders from each nation gather to claim king of the hill once a year. Who knows, maybe it should be more like the World Cup of soccer, and occur only once every two or four years. Such a step would greatly increase the anticipation of the event, draw more press coverage, and certainly make it more affordable for smaller teams such as Puerto Rico or Mongolia. Although, maybe we should just move one step at a time, and come up with a clear definition of a nation first.